_edited_edited_edited_edited.png)
Toraso - Ari Diena - מצות מעקה
- Toraso Coordinator
- Oct 1, 2024
- 1 min read
Welcome to Ari Diena to Toraso. Make sure to hound him with comments as a nice welcome! Thank you for this great Toraso presentation. The Chabura is on the Mitzvah of Maakeh, and is full of fascinating points.
R' Ari thank you so much for this Chaburah. I also loved the setup and thought it was very clear. We are excited to have you in the Chaburah. A few questions/points.
This is not a question on you, just curious. In a situation that there is an עשה ולא תעשה and a woman is not חייב from the לאו do they now become obligated in the עשה also?
Just to clarify, when you were explaining R' Akvia Eiger zt"l, you said that he holds that you can make a bracha on a קיום. I assume that still it is correct to say that on mitzvos that have no מעשה מצוה at all you still do not make a bracha,…
Great chabura and very informative!! I love the set up and the follow thrpugh of all the steps, only thing I would say is that its possible even acc to taam of motzva for both postive and negative aspects that less than4x4 and silo etc just less likely for danger to occir bec people less likwly to spend significant time in those places.
Thanks again for great chabura.
You may be right (again!!)
I was talking to someone last night about the chabura and they said osek bmitzva may be a bad question as we say that even for a hechsher mitzvah.
Once again, thanks for an awesome chabura.
R Ari,
This shticke was so enjoyable.
Your content and delivery was perfected to the point I was able to enjoy the Mesikus!!!
I want to make sure that I am on the same page as you. The mitzva of Hashavas avaida even if we would say that a misasek gets the mitzvah as he lmasah returned it. There is no doubt he is also performing the mitzva when he does whatever is needed for it. As we know oisek bmitzvah patur min hamitzvah is said on that. So your comparison isn’t a complete one.
Regarding the mitzvah of maakeh in general are you ready to say that you will not have the ptur of oisek bmitzvah when one performs…