Torah is not time bound - you read it correctly - Charoses, the stuff we eat (or do we) on Pesach at (not by - Ma) the seder. Thank you Yonah for this Chabura about Charoses. As many of you spent hours learning this over Yom Tov - I am sure that you will enjoy and likely have what to comment. Please do.
top of page
_edited_edited_edited_edited.png)
bottom of page
I listed to the chabura a while ago but forgot to post this...sorry for delay!
Beautiful Yon, I am no expert, but I agree that would be weird if the Rambam is switching on both points and therefore he has to to disagree but weird that misunderstood and I like your pshat.
BTW if you have caption on while watching its actually pretty funny 😉
Thank you, Yon, for this Chabura.
In regard to your answer for the Rambam in Pirush Hamishnayos - I am having somewhat of a hard time swallowing it. I understand that there is an achila tzura here (like Abba's point) but still does that allow for such a Bracha. On that note, I would have thought that you can use the Chasam Sofer to help your point. (He is going in the opinion of the Rambam so we can use it - and must). Possibly that is partially why he assumed that the nusach Habracha would be such. What cannot possibly imagine that the brachas is Charoses alone, like my brother, Yonah Shalom, asked -there is not achilas Charoses. Perfect…
Wow! Yonah, I really like your chabura and how clear you put together our bein hazmanim sugya! Thank you for taking the time!
I had a few thoughts I wanted to share!
If I may,
1) if my memory serves me correctly, you after explaining the the netziv you said "and that's why the rambam makes no mention of mitzva cuz you don't make a mitzva on charoses." Although it was funny how serious you were when you said it, can we assume you meant bracha? That he doesn't mention that you make a bracha just that it's a mitzva that doesn't require a bracha. Is that correct?
2) When I was in your brain and you were preparing the…